Quantcast
Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 12488

Re: Why can't this mechanism be assembled?

What stabilizes this mechanism is a very good question.  When I started this exercise, I thought that providing the 6 cylinder lengths will "fix" the pose (location and orientation) of the ee_plaform.  Essentially, I thought that Creo could solve the forward kinematics problem.  However, this is what I see:

 

     - So far as the trailing constraints are concerned: if you fix the pose of the ee-platform and ask Creo to generate the valid lengths of the six cylinders (inverse kinematics), it does just fine.

 

     - However, considering the forward kinematic problem: Creo will allow for 4 out of 6 prescribed leg-lengths to be specified and it will come up with a valid ee-platform pose.  In other situations, you'll get a cryptic error message and maybe you'll have time to spend wondering why your mechanism is not working or try ball-joints vs coincident point-point connections with varying degrees of success.

 

So in conclusion, I just have to state that given a ~$1,500 / year of maintenance fee one should expect more - I think the software should tell you why it can't find a solution, show you the alternatives, etc...  Furthermore, I just have the impression is that Dassault Systemes/Solidworks has done its work much better than PTC/Creo...


Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 12488


<script src="https://jsc.adskeeper.com/r/s/rssing.com.1596347.js" async> </script>